Posted in

Can you use canning lids for pressure canning?

If you’ve ever spent an hour scrolling canning groups on Facebook, you’ve definitely seen the debate: “Can I use my regular lids for pressure canning?” As someone who’s spent the last 8 years running a canning lids company (shoutout to everyone who’s DM’d me at 2 a.m. panicking after finding a half-used box of lids in their pantry), I get why this question pops up. Most of us have that random pack of flat canning lids sitting around—left over from last summer’s jam batch, or a clearance find at the grocery store—and when pressure canning season rolls around (hello, homegrown tomatoes and garden pickles), it feels like such a waste to buy more. But let’s cut the FOMO and the misinformation here. This isn’t a “yes or no” answer—it’s a whole, nuanced thing that hinges on what type of lids you’re actually grabbing, and what pressure canning even does that water bath canning doesn’t. Canning Lids

First, let’s get super basic: I talk to home canners every week who mix up water bath vs. pressure canning like they’re the same process. Water bath canning is for high-acid foods—jams, jellies, pickles, salsa with enough vinegar. It heats jars to a rolling boil (around 212°F) for 10 to 40 minutes, and that kills the bad stuff (like mold or yeast) that makes food spoil fast. Pressure canning is for low-acid foods—beans, meat, soup, veggies, stews. Low-acid foods can host botulism spores, which don’t die until you hit 240°F—something you only get when you seal air tight, crank the pressure gauge, and heat it to way higher temps than boiling. That’s why pressure canning isn’t just a “faster water bath”—it’s a completely different process that puts way more stress on your lids and jars.

Now, let’s talk about the lids themselves because this is where 90% of the confusion lives. When people say “canning lids,” they’re usually referring to two totally different products: flat metal lids (the ones with the rubber ring around the edge, designed for water bath canning) and screw bands (the metal rings that hold the flat lid tight to the jar). A lot of people mix these up, so let’s clarify both, because only one of them is even in the running for pressure canning—sort of.

First up: regular flat canning lids (the ones you use for water bath). These are the ones with the plastic-based sealing compound on the underside, right? They’re designed to soften at boiling temps, create a vacuum seal, and pop tight when they cool down. The big question: Can these go in a pressure canner? Short answer: Almost never. Here’s why, and I’m not just making this up—this is stuff the USDA’s home canning guidelines (the bible for all of this, trust me) has been saying for decades, and we only sell lids that meet USDA specs because we don’t want anyone getting sick. The plastic sealing compound on regular flat lids isn’t made to handle sustained temps of 240°F. When you crank a pressure canner, those compounds can break down, melt, or leach weird stuff into your food. Worse, if the lid fails mid-pressure canning, you’re not just risking a ruined jar—you’re risking botulism, which is no joke. I’ve seen too many horror stories from home canners who used regular lids, ended up with jars that leaked all over their canner, and had to dump 20 jars of homegrown green beans because they didn’t seal right. That’s a total bummer, and avoidable.

Wait, but what about the screw bands? Those are the metal rings that hold the flat lid on, right? Can I use those for pressure canning? Yeah, sometimes—but not the ones you think. Screw bands are super simple: they’re just metal, no sealing compound. The problem is, most regular screw bands you buy at the grocery store are thin, coated, or not made to handle high pressure. A lot of cheaper screw bands will bend, warp, or rust when you put them in a pressure canner, especially if you’re using a weighted-gauge canner (which hits higher pressure than dial-gauge ones, for anyone who doesn’t know). So if you want to use screw bands for pressure canning, you need to get heavy-duty, uncoated stainless steel screw bands specifically made for pressure canning. That said, even those have a catch: they’re only good for one use. Unlike the screw bands for water bath, which you can reuse a bunch of times (as long as they don’t rust or bend), pressure can screw bands are single-use because the stress of high pressure weakens their grip. We always tell customers to keep a stack of pressure-specific screw bands separate from their regular ones—no mixing them up.

Okay, so is there any lid that’s actually made for pressure canning? Let’s get to the good stuff, because this is what most people are actually asking. There are two types of lids that are safe for pressure canning: specialty metal pressure canning lids, and reusable Teflon lids (wait, no—let’s get that right, reusable silicone sealing ring lids, if you’re into that). The metal pressure canning lids are the ones we sell, by the way—they have a thick, durable sealing compound that’s designed to hold up to 240°F, multiple pressure cycles, and the stress of high pressure. They’re single-use, same as regular flat lids, but they’re engineered for the job, so you don’t have to stress about them failing. The silicone ring lids are for people who want to skip the single-use plastic lids—they’re made with food-grade silicone, so they’re heat-resistant, and you can reuse them 10 to 20 times. But here’s the thing: even those silicone lids need to be used with the right screw bands. You can’t use regular thin screw bands with them—you need the same heavy-duty pressure screw bands I mentioned earlier, because the silicone lids are heavier and need a tighter seal.

Now, let’s address the big myth that won’t die: “I used regular lids for pressure canning and nothing bad happened!” Yeah, I hear this all the time. Someone’ll post in a canning group saying they used $1 lids from the dollar store for pressure canning chicken soup, and their jars sealed, so everyone else is overreacting. But here’s the catch: that’s luck, not science. Pressure canning has variables—altitude, canner type, jar size, how tightly you tighten the bands. If one of those is off, a regular lid might fail. I once had a customer email me saying she’d been using regular lids for 3 years, no problem, until one batch of beans spoiled because the lid melted a little mid-pressure, and she didn’t notice until a week later when she opened the jar and smelled rot. That’s not a risk worth taking for a batch of homegrown veggies you spent 3 months growing. The USDA doesn’t mess around with this stuff for a reason—botulism is a silent killer, you can’t taste it or smell it, and regular lids are just not tested to handle that high heat.

Another thing people get wrong: “My pressure canning lids look exactly like my water bath lids!” No, they don’t, but only if you know what to look for. Regular flat canning lids (water bath) have thin metal tops, and the sealing compound is usually light-colored, thin, and brittle. Pressure canning lids have thicker metal tops, and the sealing compound is thicker, darker, and more flexible. If you hold them up to the light, regular lids might have tiny gaps where the compound is thin, while pressure lids are solid all the way around. And if you’re shopping for lids, don’t go for the cheapest one—we test every single lid we sell in our own pressure canner, at altitudes up to 5,000 feet, to make sure they seal every time. We’ve had customers come to us after buying a cheap bulk pack from a big box store, saying 10 out of 24 lids failed mid-pressure, and they had to dump a whole batch of pickled beets. That’s the kind of waste we’re here to help you avoid.

Wait, what about canning at high altitude? Oh, this is a whole other layer, and it’s why using the right lids matters even more. At 1,000 feet above sea level, water boils at 210°F, so you have to add 1 pound of pressure to your canner just to hit 240°F. At 5,000 feet, that’s 2 pounds of pressure, and at 7,000 feet, it’s 3 pounds. The higher you go, the longer your pressure canning time is, and the more stress you’re putting on your lids. If you’re using regular lids at high altitude, the extended time at high pressure will wear down the sealing compound way faster than it would at sea level. I live in Colorado, at 6,800 feet, so I can tell you from personal experience that my regular lids never worked for pressure canning here—they’d melt halfway through a 90-minute batch of chili. But our pressure lids? I’ve used them for 5 years, no issues, even at the highest elevations in the state.

Let’s also talk about what happens if you accidentally use the wrong lids, just to be clear. If you put a regular flat lid in the pressure canner, a few things can happen: 1) The sealing compound melts, so the lid doesn’t seal—your jar will never last more than a week in the fridge, and if you store it on the shelf, it will spoil. 2) The lid warps, so even if it seals, it will pop open when you take the canner off heat, spilling hot food all over your stove. 3) The metal splits, and little pieces of metal get into your food—gross, and dangerous. None of these are outcomes you want, especially not when you spent hours prepping that batch of homegrown tomatoes.

Now, a quick side note: what about Tattler lids? For anyone who’s into reusable canning supplies, Tattler makes silicone ring lids that are designed for both water bath and pressure canning. Those are totally safe, as long as you use the corresponding screw bands. But they’re a different product than regular or pressure flat lids, so don’t mix them up—they don’t work the same way, and they can’t be used interchangeably with metal flat lids.

At the end of the day, the answer to “can you use canning lids for pressure canning?” is: Only if they’re specifically labeled for pressure canning, and you use the right screw bands. Regular flat lids (for water bath) are off-limits, full stop. Regular screw bands are fine for water bath, but pressure canning needs heavy-duty, pressure-rated screw bands, and even those are single-use. I know buying lids for pressure canning feels like an extra cost, but trust me—compared to losing an entire batch of food, or risking foodborne illness, it’s nothing. We keep our prices low because we’re home canners too, not just a random supplier—we’ve all been there, staring at a pile of unprocessed jars, trying to figure out if we can skip a trip to the store for lids.

If you’re not sure what lids you need, or you have a question about which ones work for your canner, shoot us a message—we don’t do automated replies, we’re actual canners who know the difference between a pressure gauge and a flat lid sealing compound. We can help you pick the right lids for your altitude, your canner, and whatever you’re canning that weekend. No pressure, no pushy sales stuff—just people who want to make your canning season as stress-free as possible.

Beverage Can References
USDA. Complete Guide to Home Canning. U.S. Department of Agriculture, 2023.
National Center for Home Food Preservation. Pressure Canning Basics. University of Georgia Extension, 2022.
Ball Canning Company. Lid and Jar Compatibility Guidelines. Jarden Home Brands, 2021.


Xiamen Uniteam Sourcing Co., Ltd.
As one of the most professional canning lids manufacturers and suppliers in China, we also support customized service. Please feel free to buy high quality canning lids made in China here from our factory. For more information, contact us now.
Address: ROOM 1511, NO.939, XIAHE ROAD, SIMING DISTRICT, XIAMEN, FUJIAN, CHINA.
E-mail: operator@minjiapack.com
WebSite: https://www.minjiapacking.com/